A gardener for the City of Kirkland was feeding dead branches into a wood chipper in April 2023 when one jammed and came back at her chest. An MRI that August found a small tear in her right implant. She had both replaced at a private clinic in December, then asked Quebec’s workers’ compensation board to cover it. Her employer’s argument, as CTV News Montreal reported it in late October, was that an implant is not living tissue, so it cannot be injured at work. The labour tribunal disagreed, called the implant the equivalent of a structure of the body, and ordered half the implant cost and all of the anesthesia reimbursed.
I find the legal question interesting. I find the medical one more useful, because the branch is the rare way an implant fails and the MRI is the part most women with implants have never had. I answered a reporter’s questions on exactly this earlier in November. Here is what I said.
The Branch Is the Exception
“Breast implant shells can break down with age, become creased, or be damaged by trauma to the chest or during surgery, leading to leaks. It’s important to remember that breast implants are not ‘lifetime’ devices and the likelihood of leaks increases with implant age.”
Age and creasing, not impact, are what I see. And the kind of implant decides whether you will know.
“With saline breast implants, the salt water leaks out and the breast usually deflates within a few days, so most patients are quickly aware that something is amiss. With silicone gel breast implants, however, leaks may go undetected for years because the silicone gel typically remains contained within the scar tissue capsule that forms around the implant.”
Why the MRI Mattered
The gardener had a blow, a cry of pain and a surgeon who ordered imaging. Most ruptures have none of that.
“Keep in mind: many silicone breast implant leaks don’t cause any noticeable symptoms. That’s why the FDA recommends getting an ultrasound or MRI to check silicone breast implants beginning five to six years after implant surgery and every two to three years after that, even if you don’t have any symptoms.”
“If it’s time for your implant replacements, make an appointment with a board-certified plastic surgeon and ask for imaging studies to rule out silent silicone leaks.”
When a silicone leak does make noise, this is what it sounds like.
“Silicone leaks are more likely to result in complications including pain, inflammation, firm lumps, changes in the shape of the breast, and in some cases, capsular contracture (tightening of the scar tissue surrounding the breast implant). In some cases, the gel can travel outside of the capsule into the breast or even make its way to lymph nodes in the underarm area.”
What I Would Have Done
Her surgeon replaced both implants although only one was torn, and the tribunal paid for one. I understand the surgical call. Two implants from the same operation are the same age, and few patients want a second anesthetic for the other side in three years.
“If it’s silicone filled, the implant should be removed along with any free silicone, and you’ll have the option of implant replacement.”
“We go in, remove the capsule, remove the old implant, and put in a new one.”
And I would have used the exchange to change what goes back in. From a consult this week:
“We can switch to Motiva, which I think is the most popular one right now, because the rupture rate is so much lower that those could possibly last forever. They are guaranteed for life, so if they ever do rupture, the company will give you new ones.”
The full post, with the table of what ruptures an implant and how each cause shows up, is on Agullo Plastic Surgery; the revision page covers the operation. The imaging and consult side is on Southwest Plastic Surgery. My earlier reads on revision in five words and rippling are here on this site.
The Line That Matters
“A silicone implant can leak without a single symptom, which is why I tell my patients to know what is in their body and to keep up with imaging. Most women with implants do well, but a change in how your breast looks or feels is always worth a visit.”
Why Choose Dr. Agullo
I am certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery and the American Board of Surgery, completed my plastic surgery fellowship at the Mayo Clinic, and serve as Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center. Castle Connolly has listed me as a Top Doctor every year from 2014 through 2026, and I am a site investigator on the national Motiva post-approval study.
Ready to Talk?
Know what is in your body, and when it was last looked at. Call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or book online at agulloplasticsurgery.com/appointments. #StayBeautiful
Find me at @RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.
