“You Look Tired” Is Now a Surgical Request. Two Thirds of Facial Plastic Surgeons Hear It

Nobody asks me for a new face.

They sit down, and before I have asked a single question, they tell me what their sister said at dinner. Or their boss. Or the barista. You look tired. They slept nine hours.

The American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery has now counted that conversation. In its annual member survey, reported by Alison Werner in Plastic Surgery Practice on September 24, 66 percent of facial plastic surgeons report more patients asking for eyelid procedures to look less tired. Blepharoplasty is still a top-three facial operation with rhinoplasty and facelift. More of the people asking are men.

The Request Has Changed

The association’s president, Anthony Brissett, describes patients who want to look refreshed, not transformed. In my words:

“I think the most common reason patients come in is because people are telling them that they look tired, when they’re actually feeling just fine and feel like they have energy. A lot of them feel younger than their actual age, but the eyelids are not helping them send this message out.”

“I think patients are becoming a lot more willing to undergo facial procedures, including facelifts, because the results now are actually natural and do not change their overall appearance. So they still have a self identity after these procedures and they’re recognizable; they’re just looking ten to fifteen years younger.”

So Has the Operation

The survey piece describes a shift from routinely cutting out skin, muscle and fat to deciding what to keep, what to reposition, what to restore, and what to remove. Aging around the eyes is three-dimensional: skin, muscle, fat, brow, cheek, midface and bone.

I have been operating that way for a long time, and I explain it the same way to every patient with bags.

“Many think it is just a blepharoplasty, but I use the blepharoplasty approach to remove the fat bags, I use fat injections into the tear trough, and I use Morpheus8 microneedling with radiofrequency to tighten the skin. Sometimes I even use AccuTite to tighten the skin, avoiding an incision that can give you a visible scar, or even an ectropion.”

“I incorporate fat grafting into lower eyelid surgery, I incorporate it into all my facelifts, and I incorporate it in any facial procedure where the patient has lost a considerable amount of weight.”

Restore means fat, not filler.

“Fillers over time have started to come out of favor, as we are now noticing that the filler really never dissolves. The results can last about a year, but the filler does not dissolve, it just disperses. I have seen cases where it blocks the lymphatic drainage, and patients start having bags under the eyes, which are worse in the mornings, or they have discoloration or lumpiness.”

And restore has a limit.

“Fat is one of the procedures we perform when treating the periorbital area, and just adding volume to the tear trough can hide the under-eye bags for a while. But as they keep progressing, it comes to a point where adding volume is not going to help, and we actually need to remove those herniated fat pads.”

When the Lid Is Really the Brow

“A hooded upper eyelid is when the fold extends laterally underneath the brow and the lateral eye, and usually needs an extended incision from the blepharoplasty. A lot of times the hooding is due to the brow being low and the excess skin folding in the lateral lid. We can perform a brow lift with brow shaping through two small incisions behind the hairline on either side. This technique also reduces the amount of upper eyelid skin, and thus the upper eyelid skin resection is much shorter, and the scar therefore is shorter and doesn’t extend laterally. This also removes the heavy look from the eye and gives us a nice reshaping of the brow, usually up and lateral, which looks more youthful. It’s usually combined with some fat grafting above the orbital rim as well.”

“There are three objective findings that will let us know whether a brow lift or temporal lift is indicated. The first is that the patient is usually forcefully raising their brows, and you can see the wrinkles in the lateral forehead as the patient raises the brows so they can see better. The second finding is if the brow sits right on top of the orbital rim, that is the bone right above the eye. In females, the brow should be one or two centimeters above the rim. If it’s right on the rim, then it means there is ptosis, and it can be improved with a brow lift, brow reshaping, or temporal lift. The last test is actually moving the brow with our finger up and out. If the lateral eye hooding resolves, then a brow shaping or endoscopic lift is indicated.”

Upper or Lower

“Upper eyelids versus lower eyelids. Most patients come in for one or the other, but they may actually benefit from working on both. I think the lower eyelids are a lot more common, with people complaining about their lower eyelid bags, and these are maybe slightly younger patients. The older patients are definitely concerned about their upper eyelids, the hooding, and even the visual impairment it’s causing.”

“It seems to be the first part of the face that patients notice as they age, especially the upper eyelid skin, which can hang and even rest on the eyelashes, giving the patient the impression of being tired and even making makeup hard to put on.”

The Men

“Number three is eyelid surgery. I see it more and more frequently, especially the upper eyelids, but oftentimes upper and lower eyelids and the tear trough deformity.”

“When we do facelifts, we do not like to raise the brow as much. In men, it should pretty much line up with the superior orbital rim.”

“Upper blepharoplasty in men is shorter than in women, and I usually don’t chase the lateral hooding unless the patient specifically asks for it. The reason is that most men don’t use makeup, and hiding that lateral extension can be difficult. If there is lateral hooding in men, I strongly advise an endoscopic brow lift and brow shaping to raise the brow and address the lateral eye hooding. This keeps the incision short, so that when the patient opens his eyes, the scar hides in the natural eyelid fold.”

“In lower blepharoplasty, I almost never excise the excess skin. I perform the incision transconjunctival, which means through the inside of the eyelid, so there is no visible scar. The skin tightening is achieved with laser, Morpheus8, or AccuTite, and I almost always graft fat and nanofat into the tear trough and above the orbital rim.”

“Recovery for men is usually seven to ten days, but many return to work sooner, as there is really no pain after eyelid surgery; it’s mostly just the bruising and swelling. We do coach men on how to use makeup to hide bruising if it’s still present when they want to return to work, and we also recommend thick-rimmed eyeglasses to hide the area around the eyes during recovery. Elixir MD LED therapy helps with reducing recovery time.”

Rested, not transformed. For a man, that sentence is the whole consultation.

Why Choose Dr. Agullo

Double board-certified, by the American Board of Plastic Surgery and the American Board of Surgery. Mayo Clinic plastic surgery fellowship. Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center. Castle Connolly Top Doctor for 13 consecutive years. The full version of this post is on agulloplasticsurgery.com.

Ready to Talk?

Nine hours of sleep and still “you look tired.” That is not a sleep problem.

Call the office at (915) 590-7900, text us at 1-866-814-0038, or book a consultation at agulloplasticsurgery.com/appointments. #StayBeautiful

@RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.