One performance. One screenshot. One very long comment thread.
In early November, K-pop fans spent a weekend arguing over whether a member of SEVENTEEN, The8, had rhinoplasty, because his nose appeared different to them from one stage to the next. Koreaboo carried the debate on November 2. Some fans were sure. Others pointed at the lighting. Nobody asked a surgeon, and nobody has any business diagnosing a stranger from a screenshot, so I will not. I have no idea what he has or has not done, and neither does anyone in that thread.
What I can tell you is what a nose does after surgery, day by day, because I watch it every week. A one-day change is almost never a rhinoplasty. The timeline does not allow it.
Day One to Day Seven: You Cannot See the Nose
This is the part the overnight theory skips. After a rhinoplasty the nose is not visible. It is under a splint.
“Surgery is about two to two and a half hours, general anesthesia, home the same day. Splints go on the outside and the inside, so you will be stuffy for about seven days, and then everything comes off. At that point your breathing should be better.”
“You will have a splint on the outside and on the inside that’s gonna be there for a week, and then after a week we’ll take everything off. You’ll see the new nose, but it’s still gonna be a little bit swollen.”
A performer cannot hide a splint under stage makeup. Whoever had surgery that week was not on stage that week.
Week One to Week Six: It Looks Like a Nose, Not the Nose
The splint comes off and the shape is there. It is also swollen, and swelling reads as width.
“The nose will still be swollen. It takes a couple of weeks to start looking better and better, and by about six weeks we are pretty close to the final shape. The nose itself takes about a whole year to keep refining.”
“Only about twenty percent of my patients get bruising under the eyes, and when it happens it takes about two weeks to fade and covers easily with makeup.”
“Usually most people after ten days are okay with other people seeing them, putting on a little makeup if you have any bruising.”
So a fresh rhinoplasty on a stage looks puffier, not slimmer. If a nose looks narrower than it did last month, swelling is not the explanation either way.
Week Six to Month Twelve: The Slow Part
Most of the change shows early. The refinement takes the rest of the year, and it moves in one direction.
“It starts looking really good at six weeks, but it keeps getting better and better for a whole year. So it is a long process, but most of it is really in the beginning.”
“Judging your nose at two weeks is judging a nose that is not finished.”
“If you wanna look your best for Christmas, at least six weeks before.”
That last line is what I tell patients who have an event coming. The idea of a nose quietly turning into a different nose between two shows a few days apart is not how tissue heals.
What Does Change a Nose in a Day
Plenty of things, and none of them are surgery.
| What fans saw | What it usually is |
|---|---|
| A slimmer bridge under stage lights | Hard side light and contour makeup narrowing the dorsum |
| A sharper tip on camera | Lens distance; a long lens flattens and refines, a phone up close widens |
| A different profile | A three-quarter angle versus straight on, and head tilt |
| A smaller nose overall | Weight loss in the face, which makes every feature read smaller |
| A nose that “changed” over a few weeks | Swelling settling from a procedure done months ago, or nothing at all |
There is one treatment that can change a nose in an afternoon, and it is the one I argue with patients about: filler.
“Filler is going to make your nose bigger. All we do with filler is cheat by adding to other places.”
“What we see now is that filler in the nose does not really go away. It spreads. It ends up on the sides, and in the end it makes you look wide.”
So a liquid rhinoplasty can shift a profile overnight. It cannot make a nose smaller, and it tends to make it wider over time. If a nose looks narrower, filler is not the story.
What a Good Rhinoplasty Should Look Like
The honest tell of surgery is not a one-day change. It is a nose that does not fit the face.
“A nose that is too small for the face reads as surgery. A nose that fits reads as a nose.”
“The idea is for the width of your nose to match the corner of your eye.”
“I do an open rhinoplasty, so there is one small incision on the columella, the strip of skin between the nostrils. Everything else is done from the inside. You are going to have a scar, but it is going to be very hard to see.”
When the proportions are right, people stop looking at the nose, which is the whole point, and which is why a careful result gets argued about online for a weekend and then forgotten.
The Timeline, in One Place
Week one, splint on, nose hidden. Week one to six, visible but swollen, bruising in about one patient in five. Six weeks, close to final; exercise can resume. One year, the last refinement, especially at the tip. The surgical side of that first year, what each week looks like and what it costs, is on my practice site. What actually helps swelling settle faster is on Southwest Plastic Surgery. I wrote about a broken nose consult in September and about what a rhinoplasty costs in August.
Why Choose Dr. Agullo
I am certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery and the American Board of Surgery, completed my plastic surgery fellowship at the Mayo Clinic, and serve as Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center. Castle Connolly has listed me as a Top Doctor every year from 2014 through 2026. Rhinoplasty and revision rhinoplasty are a steady part of my practice in El Paso, with 3D imaging at the consult so you see the plan before anyone operates.
Ready to Talk?
Wondering what your own nose would look like, and how long it would take? Come in and look at it in 3D with me. Call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or request an appointment at agulloplasticsurgery.com/appointments. #StayBeautiful
Find me at @RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.
