Toxic-Phobic, With Implants: What Jenny McCarthy’s Answer Gets Right About Breast Implants and Mold

Jenny McCarthy, smiling, long blonde waves, black sleeveless turtleneck, on the red carpet at the Malibu Film Festival for An Inconvenient Study, Hollywood, October 2025. Editorial photo, mwood99 / Shutterstock.com. Commentary by Frank Agullo, MD, FACS.

Jenny McCarthy has been candid about a rough two years: dental infections, oral surgeries, growths on her eyelids, and a functional medicine doctor who, she says, told her she had mold and mycotoxin poisoning. In October she said she was sleeping in a tent during a mold detox. She calls herself “toxic-phobic.” So a listener put the obvious question to her on the November 3 episode of her podcast: then why the breast implants?

Jenny McCarthy, smiling, long blonde waves, black sleeveless turtleneck, on the red carpet at the Malibu Film Festival for An Inconvenient Study, Hollywood, October 2025. Editorial photo, mwood99 / Shutterstock.com. Commentary by Frank Agullo, MD, FACS.
Jenny McCarthy at the Malibu Film Festival for An Inconvenient Study, Hollywood, October 12, 2025. Editorial credit: mwood99 / Shutterstock.com

“Touché. You are correct,” she said, per Entertainment Weekly and Yahoo. Maybe when she is older. Not now.

The internet treated that as a contradiction. I do not. A reporter asked me about the story the next morning, and my answers, quoted below word for word, are the same ones I give in my office.

The Mold Question Has a Short Answer

“Is there a link to mold or mycotoxin poisoning? The answer is no, there is no established link. There are case reports of fungal growth inside breast implants, but this is incredibly rare and limited to saline breast implants that are much older. This is completely different from implants making someone sick from being in a moldy house. If you think you’re getting sick from mold you should seek medical attention to figure out what’s going on.”

A modern silicone gel implant is a cohesive gel in a shell. There is nothing in it for a fungus to live on. The case reports people pass around are old saline implants, opened at removal, with growth inside the water. That is a curiosity in the literature, not a mechanism for illness, and it has nothing to do with a house.

What Breast Implant Illness Is, and Is Not

The real conversation is the one nobody on the podcast used the words for.

“Some patients do have … breast implant illness (a constellation of symptoms including fatigue, brain fog, and joint pain that is not well understood, does not have a formal diagnosis, but some patients do feel better after explant).”

I take it seriously and I am honest about its limits in the same breath.

“If you have had your implants all this time and felt fine, you are probably never going to have that problem. It is pretty rare. Of the thousands of breast augmentations I have done, maybe ten or a dozen women have wanted their implants out because they felt the implants were affecting them. And they usually do feel better when we remove them.”

“But I am honest about this part: a lot of the time we do not really know whether it was the implants or something else. As you get older you start getting some aches and fatigue anyway, and those are normal parts of aging. If you have implants, it is natural to blame them.”

When a patient does decide the implants go, here is what my own practice has taught me to expect.

“I would say eighty percent feel better, but twenty percent say it wasn’t the implants, and many of them come back and have implants put in again.”

Why Her Answer Is the Right Kind of Answer

She did not claim her implants were safe because a celebrity said so, and she did not rip them out because the internet asked her to. She said she likes them, she has already downsized from what she was given at 19 or 20, and she may revisit it later. That is exactly the frame I want a patient in.

“If your breast implants aren’t bothering you, you love the way they look, and they’ve been in place for years and years without complication, staying with them is totally fair. Explant is still surgery with a recovery and the breasts will probably be looser or flatter, and some patients will want a breast lift at time of explant to be happier with their breast contour.”

The reporting says her current implants are Motiva. That detail matters more than the mold talk, because it changes the maintenance math.

“The Motiva implants I use now have a very low rupture rate, under half a percent, and a very low rate of capsular contracture, also around half a percent, compared with ten to fifteen percent for some older implants. Because of that, I do not tell patients they have to swap them every ten years the way we did with the old ones.”

What I Would Tell Her, and You

“If you’re considering explant I encourage you to: Know your breast implants (saline or silicone? Textured or smooth? How old are they?) Have the imaging studies suggested by your surgeon. Be on the lookout for changes including pain, swelling, lump, breast implant shape change. Consult with a board-certified plastic surgeon to discuss breast contour changes (will you need a breast lift?)”

The full version of this, with the complication table, how I examine an implant a patient blames and what explant and a lift involve, is on Agullo Plastic Surgery. The checkup side, what to bring and when to image, is on Southwest Plastic Surgery. What actually ruptures an implant was last week’s read, and the revision conversation in five words is here.

The Line I Want You to Keep

“If your implants are intact and you feel well, keeping them is a valid choice, and if you want them out, that is valid too. What matters is that the decision is based on what we know, not on fear. Right now there is no evidence that implants cause mold illness, but changes in your breasts should never be ignored.”

Why Choose Dr. Agullo

I am certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery and the American Board of Surgery, trained in plastic surgery at the Mayo Clinic, and teach as Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center. Castle Connolly has listed me as a Top Doctor every year from 2014 through 2026. I remove, exchange and revise implants every week, and I am a site investigator on the national Motiva post-approval study.

Ready to Talk?

Unsure whether your implants stay or go? Bring your implant card and let me look. Call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or book online at agulloplasticsurgery.com/appointments. #StayBeautiful

Find me at @RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.

The Breast Augmentation Quote Nobody Explains: Why $7,000 Is Just the Starting Line

Black and white editorial photograph of a confident woman in a bikini, viewed from behind, looking at her own reflection in a mirror. Breast augmentation cost commentary by Frank Agullo, MD, FACS.

Breast augmentation is the most searched procedure I perform, and the price is the first thing anyone looks for. Fair enough. I publish mine. Starting at $7,000 for saline, $8,000 for silicone, $8,500 to $9,000 for a gummy bear implant. What I won’t do is pretend that starting number is the only number, because it isn’t, and any surgeon who tells you otherwise before an exam is guessing.

Here’s what I’d want to know if I were the one asking.

What the Starting Price Actually Includes

Our published price is real, and it’s genuinely inclusive. It covers the surgery center, the operating room, anesthesia, and an anesthesiologist. It covers my fee. It covers a pair of implants. It covers the post-surgical bra, scar treatments, moisturizer, and vitamins. It covers your pre-op workup and every post-op visit. The only thing it doesn’t cover is your prescription medications, which you pick up at the pharmacy like anyone else.

That’s a longer list than most patients expect, and it’s exactly why I publish it. Better-educated patients walk into a consultation already knowing what they’re buying instead of getting surprised by it afterward.

Why the Number Moves From One Surgeon to the Next

Location changes the number. Overhead is higher in some markets than others, for the surgeon and for the surgery center both. What the anesthesia team charges changes it. What a surgeon can negotiate on implants, antibiotics, and supplies changes it. Experience changes it too. Surgeons in high demand are usually the ones who deliver consistent results safely, and that reputation carries a cost.

When a price looks too good to be true, it usually is. Somewhere, a corner is getting cut. I use a Keller funnel for a no-touch technique when I insert implants, which drives up cost but lowers infection risk. I use Exparel to create a chest block, injecting long-lasting anesthesia between the ribs, which keeps patients more comfortable after surgery. I schedule enough OR time to work at a paced, careful speed instead of rushing to save on anesthesia minutes. Patients get direct access to our nursing staff twenty-four hours a day. Every case happens in an accredited surgical center built for real emergencies, not just routine ones. None of that is free, and none of it should be.

Saline, Silicone, or Gummy Bear: The Implant Sets the Floor

Implant type Where it lands Why
Saline Least expensive Simplest implant, adjustable fill volume
Silicone Mid-range More natural feel, higher material cost
Gummy bear Highest of the standard options Cohesive gel, lowest rupture profile
Mentor enhanced oversized (800cc+) Highest overall Premium sizing tier, priced accordingly

I recommend the gummy bear category, and Motiva specifically, more than any other option. Motiva carries the lowest capsular contracture rate and the lowest rupture rate of any implant I place, with one of the strongest warranties in the industry, one that can even cover surgical costs if a complication like contracture or rupture happens down the road, or if a patient simply changes her mind.

What Actually Pushes a Quote Higher

A revision that needs more OR time and a more involved technique costs more than a straightforward first surgery. A donut lift or a full lift added to the augmentation costs more. Mesh support, GalaFLEX or DuraSorb functioning as an internal bra, adds cost. A premium implant, especially the Mentor enhanced oversized line, costs more than a standard Motiva or Mentor silicone implant. A longer anticipated surgery time costs more. A transaxillary approach, through the armpit, takes longer than an inframammary or periareolar incision and prices accordingly.

Past that list, there really isn’t a hidden fee. We offer package discounts when a patient combines procedures, but nothing is required. If a case runs long or hits a complication, the patient still pays what was quoted. That’s the deal.

What I Tell a Patient Who Feels Priced Out

Think long-term. You’re paying for reduced complications, a better result, and a surgeon who’s board-certified specifically in plastic surgery rather than someone practicing outside their training. Cheaper packages skip the parts that actually protect you: the better warranty, the internal mesh bra, Exparel, triple antibiotic irrigation, a no-touch technique. Financing exists for a reason. We work with PatientFi, AlphaEon, Cherry, and CareCredit, plus a direct payment plan through the practice itself, paid at your own pace before surgery.

Eighty percent of our patients travel from other cities to have this done here. Not because it’s cheaper. It usually isn’t. They come for the reviews, the before-and-afters we post almost daily, and the fact that so many of our patients come back for something else once they’ve experienced the practice firsthand.

Consultation, 3D Imaging, and Insurance

There’s a separate consultation fee to see me, in person or virtually, and it’s applied toward your procedure if you move forward. That consultation includes 3D imaging with Crisalix, where you can see different implant sizes and brands on your own body before committing to anything, plus time with real sizers in the room. It also lets us catch volume asymmetry between breasts early, and flag whether a lift should happen at the same time.

I no longer take insurance, since I perform these as cosmetic procedures. Reconstruction after breast cancer or for congenital asymmetry is a different category, and I’ll refer you to a colleague who handles that. Some patients with a medical reason still choose to see me on a cash-pay basis, for the results and the experience, and that’s their call to make.

Why This Sits in a Surgical Practice, Not a Price Chart

I did my plastic surgery fellowship at Mayo Clinic and I’m a Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center Paul L. Foster School of Medicine. Castle Connolly has named me a Top Doctor for thirteen straight years. Breast augmentation, including the preservation technique with Motiva Preserve, is one of the procedures I do most. That’s the reason I’d rather explain a real number honestly than quote a flat one I can’t stand behind.

Ready to Talk?

Skip the forum number. Come in, and I’ll tell you what actually goes into your quote, implant by implant.

Call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or book online at agulloplasticsurgery.com/appointments. #StayBeautiful.

@RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.


  • Patient-facing version on agulloplasticsurgery.com: “What Breast Augmentation Actually Costs in El Paso (And Why the Number Moves)” (link once live)
  • Practice version on swplasticsurgery.com: “What Breast Augmentation Costs at Southwest Plastic Surgery” (link once live)