Three Perfect Photos Is a Red Flag: How to Read a Surgeon’s Before-and-After Feed

Black and white photograph of a person seen from behind and over the shoulder, scrolling a smartphone whose screen is a blank glow, single hard side light against deep shadow. Illustrative image, not a patient. Commentary by Frank Agullo, MD, FACS.

I have posted before-and-afters since 2014. This is not a post against them. It is about how to read them.

Marc McKee of This Is My Journey is 126 pounds down on a GLP-1. He asked me what the photos hide. Here is the exchange, as I said it.

Marc: What do you most want people to understand about surgery that before-and-after culture online hides?

Me: I would stay away from anybody that has one or two or three amazing before and afters and that’s it. You want to see a surgeon that’s posting before and afters every day, and they’re all consistent, and they’re all getting good results. They’re not going to all be home runs, because it depends how the patient comes in. You can’t get a home run out of everybody, but you can definitely get them to a better place as long as the expectations are set.

Three photos is a portfolio. A daily feed is a track record.

Me: The before and after doesn’t tell the whole story. It doesn’t tell you about the patient’s psychology, if they’re happy or not. You don’t know that from a photo. Some patients get amazing results and they’re still not happy; they have these little things they want to perfect. It doesn’t tell you about the recovery, everything they had to go through, or any complications there could have been. And of course the cost the patient had to undergo, what it cost the family, just getting through the whole procedure. The before and after is a quick fast-forward through all of that. But it is an important part of choosing a surgeon, because you want to see somebody that can consistently deliver good results.

Psychology. Recovery. Complications. Cost. None of it is in the frame.

Marc: How do you handle it when someone wants something surgery can’t give?

Me: That’s the toughest part of my job, telling patients that’s not possible. Realistic expectations. We have to set that from the beginning, otherwise nobody’s going to be happy. I’m not going to be happy, the patient’s not going to be happy, it’s going to be a sad story. Thankfully, with social media and the way we’ve been educating patients, less behind the curtain, patients are having a lot more realistic expectations. Some patients bring wish photos and you have to coach them. You have to tell them, this patient you’re showing me is 20 years old, you’re 40. Or this patient’s BMI is 20 and you’re still at 30. You look much better than you did before, but we can’t compare apples to oranges.

Bring the wish photo anyway. We will talk about it.

Me: And realistic expectations afterwards too. Patients who have lost a lot of weight, we do these surgeries and we’re pulling as tight as we can, but the skin, because it’s lost that elastin, is going to give again. We lose some of the result over the first six months. Another realistic expectation is that a lot of times, six months later, we have to do a little nip and tuck to tighten things up and get them right.

That is the part nobody posts. The early after is pulled tight. The six-month after has settled. A small revision does not photograph.

Marc: What made a Mayo-trained plastic surgeon decide to show the public what happens in an operating room?

Me: Before, I would have a consultation with a patient in front of me and they were so anxious and worried, and I was giving them all this information, and I think it just went in one side and came out the other. At the end of the consultation they were more confused than before. Now they come in and they know what’s going on. They’re telling me what they want. I start explaining and they’re like, yeah, yeah, I know, I know. It’s a lot more comfortable, and I think they are better for it.

Marc: What does #StayBeautiful mean and why is it significant to you?

Me: This is one of the slogans we came up with early on. Everybody’s beautiful when they come in. We’re helping you become the best version of yourself, and we’re working as a team to get there, but it doesn’t mean that if you don’t have plastic surgery you’re not beautiful. There are certain things that make each person beautiful, and it’s not always the physical. The other slogan we say a lot is happy is beautiful. If you’re happy, you’re beautiful.

So read the feed all the way down. Your age. Your BMI. Their ordinary result, not their best one. Then remember the after is month one of a six-month story.

The five-minute license and board check comes before any of this. The rest of what I said on the podcast, on loose skin and timing, is here.

Call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or book at agulloplasticsurgery.com. #StayBeautiful

Find me at @RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.

A Quarter of What You Lost Was Muscle: A Surgeon on the Whole-Body Deflation

Black and white photograph of a person in a fitted dark athletic top seen from behind, shoulders and upper back lit by a single hard side light against deep shadow. Illustrative image, not a patient. Commentary by Frank Agullo, MD, FACS.

The tummy is the part everybody plans for. It is the part they have been pinching in the mirror for years, the part the tummy tuck was invented for. So when a patient a hundred pounds lighter sits down across from me, they are ready for that conversation.

They are not ready for the rest of it. I said as much on a podcast last week, to a host 126 pounds down, and I have written up the timing half already. This is the other half.

“It’s a 360 thing. It’s the whole body, not just the tummy like most people expect.”

Start with the physics, because it explains everything after it.

“The skin envelope has been stretched out. It’s lost those connections with elastin, and you can’t make any new elastin. Once you deflate, just like a balloon, the outside wrinkles. We’re going to get some contracture, it’s just not as much as we would want.”

A balloon does not wrinkle in one spot. So, zone by zone.

The breasts, and I mean both sexes.

“The breast loses its fat content, and this is for both men and women, which is also surprising. You suddenly have saggy breasts, and that can affect a lot of patients mentally.”

The men are the ones blindsided. Fixable. Not the reward they pictured.

The buttock is the one I want you to understand, because it deflates twice.

“The same thing happens in the buttock area, and there we have a combination. A lot of these patients losing weight fast are not taking in enough protein, so they’re also losing muscle. About a quarter of the weight loss is going to be muscle mass. So the body loses muscle mass plus the fatty content, and then we have the sagging in the buttock.”

A quarter of it is muscle. The buttock is mostly muscle. So the weight-loss months matter here.

“It depends on the amount of weight you lose, how fast you do it, and how you take care of yourself during that time. Are you taking protein? Are you doing weightlifting and building muscle? The skin is going to react the way it does. We can’t do a lot about it. We can help it in some ways, but you shouldn’t feel bad if you have excess skin.”

Then the zones nobody mentions until I ask.

“Some patients have it in the inner thighs, the arms, the back.”

Inner thighs rub. Arms show in a short sleeve. The trunk I covered in the body lift post.

Will it come back if you wait? Some.

“Younger patients are going to retract better. Everybody retracts some, probably not as much as we would want, and it’s also sooner than people think. It really happens in the early stages, and I think at a maximum of a year it’s all done.”

A year is the ceiling.

Where do I start?

“If you’re losing 40 pounds, I think you’re going to need a surgical procedure. It depends: some people care about the face, some about the buttocks, so it’s very personal what gives the patient the self-confidence.”

The face changes first. You rank the rest, not me.

Timing, which I laid out here:

“What I’ve been seeing is about a six to nine month weight loss and then about a three month stabilization until we’re ready for surgery.”

“And the main thing is not to bounce back. When you stop taking it, if we have a bounce back, that can pretty much destroy everything we did, and the fat is not going to come back in the right places necessarily.”

One last thing, usually said as an apology.

“Patients lose the weight, the envelope stays, and some patients feel ashamed of it, like they did something wrong. That’s not the fact. It’s just the way things work. Skin stops producing elastin after puberty, so it just doesn’t contract like it does during puberty.”

You did the hard part. The skin is the part I do.

The full clinical version, with the zone-by-zone table and the procedure pages, is on agulloplasticsurgery.com.

Call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or book at agulloplasticsurgery.com. #StayBeautiful

Find me at @RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.

The Skin Doesn’t Know You Lost the Weight the Healthy Way: My Conversation on This Is My Journey

Episode artwork for This Is My Journey podcast, season 3 episode 5, The Envelope Problem, with a black and white portrait of Dr. Frank Agullo, MD, FACS, plastic surgeon, and host Marc McKee.

Marc McKee lost 126 pounds on Mounjaro. Two years in, he still had questions about his skin. So he asked me all of them, on camera, for 28 minutes.

The episode went live this week on his podcast, This Is My Journey. It is the GLP-1 show out of the UK that people on these medications actually listen to, because Marc is one of them.

Watch it here, then read on for what we got into.

The Volume Goes, The Envelope Stays: Loose Skin and Ozempic Face. This Is My Journey, season 3, episode 5. Watch on YouTube.

The line Marc could not stop thinking about

He opened with something I had said before, and asked me to explain it. The skin doesn’t know you lost the weight the healthy way.

“It’s true, the skin doesn’t know how you did it. Patients lose the weight, the envelope stays, and some patients feel ashamed of it, like they did something wrong. That’s not the fact. It’s just the way things work. Skin stops producing elastin after puberty, so it just doesn’t contract like it does during puberty.”

“You shouldn’t feel bad if you have excess skin. It’s part of losing weight, and everybody’s different. Even with pregnancy, some women spring right back and it looks like nothing ever happened, and some don’t.”

That is the whole episode in two answers. The rest is detail.

Why the face goes first

Marc wanted the deflation story for the whole body, not just the tummy. Here is the part that surprises people.

“The biggest surprise patients see is the change in their face. The face doesn’t have a lot of fat, but the fat it does have is the good fat, the baby fat, what makes you look young. In the face you see the loss of the fat under the eyes, the temporal areas, temporal wasting, the buccal fat. We see the face just melt down because it’s lost all that volume.”

I wrote a full post on that face last week, what deflation does and why the fix is fat. The episode is the spoken version.

And it is not only the face.

“The breast loses its fat content, and this is for both men and women, which is also surprising. You suddenly have saggy breasts, and that can affect a lot of patients mentally. The same thing happens in the buttock area. A lot of these patients losing weight fast are not taking in enough protein, so they’re also losing muscle. About a quarter of the weight loss is going to be muscle mass.”

“It’s a 360 thing. It’s the whole body, not just the tummy like most people expect.”

The timing question, answered out loud

This is the question I get in every consult now, and Marc asked it plainly. How stable does the weight need to be?

“We had everything standardized for bariatric surgery. They would lose weight for a year or a year and a half, stabilize, and then we would wait six months. With GLP-1s, patients are losing the weight a lot faster, getting to goal faster, and plateauing faster. What I’ve been seeing is about a six to nine month weight loss and then about a three month stabilization until we’re ready for surgery.”

“If you’re losing 40 pounds, I think you’re going to need a surgical procedure.”

And the one thing that undoes all of it:

“The main thing is not to bounce back. When you stop taking it, if we have a bounce back, that can pretty much destroy everything we did, and the fat is not going to come back in the right places necessarily.”

What the before-and-after photo leaves out

Near the end Marc asked what before-and-after culture online hides. I have opinions.

“I would stay away from anybody that has one or two or three amazing before and afters and that’s it. You want to see a surgeon that’s posting before and afters every day, and they’re all consistent.”

“The before and after doesn’t tell the whole story. It doesn’t tell you about the patient’s psychology, if they’re happy or not. It doesn’t tell you about the recovery, everything they had to go through, or any complications there could have been. The before and after is a quick fast-forward through all of that.”

Who should watch

Anyone on a GLP-1 who has started to notice their face before their waistline. Anyone at goal weight wondering whether the skin will tighten on its own if they wait. And anyone whose family keeps saying “you look great” while they are quietly avoiding mirrors.

Marc is 37, two years in, and still on the road. He asked the questions the way a patient asks them. I answered the way I do in the exam room.

Why me, and why this show

I am a double board-certified plastic surgeon, Mayo Clinic fellowship trained, and a Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech’s Paul L. Foster School of Medicine. Massive weight loss surgery has been part of my practice since before the pen existed. Marc built This Is My Journey for people who could not find straight answers, and that is the same reason I started filming surgery in 2014. We were always going to get along.

Watch the episode, then send me the question he did not ask.

Ready to talk?

If you have lost the weight and want a surgeon’s read on the skin, call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or book at agulloplasticsurgery.com. #StayBeautiful

Find me at @RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.