I draw the incision on the skin with my finger, and the next question is almost always the same one. This week it came from a patient with an old scar over a joint that healed thick, from a patient who is pale and expects the worst, from a patient with two areola scars that stretched wide, and from a patient finishing a course of Accutane. I am publishing the exchanges nearly as they happened, identifiers removed.
The patient with the ugly scar
Her: The scarring. I’ve had surgeries before, but this one kind of healed really ugly.
Me: “That’s typical of any scars over the joints. They’re always gonna be worse. So the ones that we can control, like in the breast and in the abdomen, they usually do much better. We will be doing taping and then silicone taping, and then we’re gonna be using a scar cream. So we’ll be on top of it to try to get the best scar we possibly can. And the good thing is that the way I place all these scars, they’re really gonna be hidden by underwear or a bathing suit, or the bra or a bikini top. So all of them are gonna be easy to hide.”
Her: And you said it would have to be from here to here?
Me: “Yeah, it’s where your fold ends, but it is in the underwear or bikini line, so it’s easy to hide. And going that far allows me to remove the excess that you have on the side, because if we only do the front, then you’d keep the sides, like wings, or we call them dog ears.”
The pale patient
Her: I feel like my stomach’s okay. But I’m pale, so I scar pretty intensely. I have concerns about scars.
Me: “You should actually scar very well. Because the lighter you are, the better the scars are. There are areas where everybody scars bad. So elbows, knees, any joint, or in the chest area, everybody’s going to get a bad scar. But in other places, usually the lighter the skin, the easier the scar is.”
She was also asking about her inner thighs, and that is the one incision I warn everybody about.
Me: “Whenever we do a medial thigh lift, I can tell you almost a hundred percent of the time something will open up a little bit, so it does take some changing the gauze until it heals, so that delays the recovery a little bit. Usually it heals perfectly well. We don’t have to do any scar revision or anything, but there’s so much tension in that area that it always opens up a little.”
The patient with a C-section scar
Her: You said it was gonna be an extended? My C-section scar is from here to here.
Me: “Yeah, we’re gonna remove that, and then it’s gonna go, in your case, to about here.”
Her: Does it go like a smile type of position?
Me: “It follows your crease right now. Your underwear, you’re not wearing it that high, so it would probably not be a good idea to put it that high. It’s more in the panty line.”
The patient with stretched areolas
Me: “So I think that we have a good chance if I just stick to really not trying to make them much smaller, but just the scar. It has to be full thickness, but I think we can get it, because it’s still soft, so it’s not very tight. So we’ll just be redoing both areolas, and hopefully try to avoid having to do the vertical. One of the things we’ve started using is microneedling and PDGF, which is a platelet-derived growth factor. I can inject that during the surgery, and then you can actually take some home and apply it in the scar, and it does seem to really make the healing a lot faster.”
Her: Would it have to be under general?
Me: “This can be under IV. But not local. It’s a very sensitive area. And it would take like an hour, and then you go home the same day. You can go back to work probably in two, three days, and then exercise we would wait at least two to three weeks, four weeks to be sure.”
The patient who wanted an old scar gone
Her: There’s some scars on the side of my eyes. Is that something that can be removed?
Me: “At the time we do the blepharoplasty we will revise those. We can’t get rid of scars, but we can make them look better. I have to cut them out and close them, and then do the wound care and everything so that it heals better than it did the first time.”
She also had a scar above the brow from an old brow lift.
Me: “The absolute best way to hide that scar is to actually take some hairs from the back and transplant them in front of the scar so it hides it. It’s hair that we move from the back into the front and it’s gonna grow really well. The other option is for me to try to redo your scar, but it may heal the same again. So if we can actually hide it, it’s even better.”
The patient worried about a scar on her nose
Her: I don’t know if I’ll do anything on the side, because I don’t think that I want that scar.
Me: “That scar heals pretty well. The most important thing is in the beginning keeping it very clean, because if a scab builds up, then you get the little indent. But afterwards, we can do microneedling, and it’s going to be right on that ridge, and you have the advantage that you use makeup to conceal it. So it’s really not that bad. In guys, it’s something I tell them to really think about, because you have no way of hiding it.”
Her mother: She tends to scar strong sometimes.
Me: “There are areas in the body where everybody scars bad. One is the chest, and then any joint, like elbows, knees. In the face, everybody usually scars really, really well. I’ve actually never seen a keloid on the nose.”
The patient on Accutane
Her: And with Accutane? They told me I should be done this month.
Me: “The only worry we have with Accutane, it’s really when we do work on the face, because they can scar. This is such a small incision that really we don’t worry about it. Accutane only really affects the skin, and it’s right on the fold, so it’s really not an absolute contraindication. Worst case, if your scar doesn’t come out beautiful, once you’re off Accutane we can revise it and make it look better. But we’ve done patients before, and they do perfectly fine. You just have to do a lot of moisturizer, so that when we put in the implant, I would even start today, so that we avoid stretch marks.”
What all of them heard, in some form
Scars depend on how much skin you have. Skin type, location and tension decide most of the result before the first stitch goes in. My part is to put the line in a crease or under clothing, keep the tension off it, and stay on top of it with tape, silicone and cream. If a scar still disappoints us, I cut it out and close it again, and sometimes the better answer is to hide it under hair.
I am a double board-certified plastic surgeon, a Mayo Clinic fellowship alum, and I teach plastic surgery as a Clinical Associate Professor at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center.
Call the office at (915) 590-7900, text us at 1-866-814-0038, or book a consultation at drworldwide.com.
#StayBeautiful
@RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.
