The eyes are where people notice age first. They are also where the smallest, best-hidden procedures in my whole practice live.
Patients point at the same things. Heavy upper lids. Puffy lower bags. Hollows that read as exhaustion no matter how much they sleep. And, very often, old under-eye filler that simply never went away.
Here is how I talk about the eyes, candidly.
“Heavy, Uneven Upper Lids. Is That a Muscle Problem?”
Usually not. A true lazy eye is a muscle issue, but in most cases both lids line up the same distance from the pupil, which tells me the problem is the fold and the weight of extra skin, not the muscle.
The fix for the upper lid is surprisingly minor. I remove the fold of skin, and the scar sits inside the new crease. When you open your eyes, you do not see it.
“Will Surgery Change the Shape of My Eye?”
No, and this is the worry I hear most. I am only removing the fold. In most cases I do not extend out to the side, I finish right at the crease, and that is what avoids the pulled, changed look. Your crease is already drawn by your own anatomy, so I follow it. The goal is more symmetric, not different. Faces are always a little different side to side, so I make it better, not identical.
What Eye Bags Actually Are
Lower eyelid surgery removes the fat bag. If you keep your face still and roll your eyes up, you will watch the bags pop out more. Those are what come out.
I do it through an incision on the inside of the lid, so there is no scar on the outside and no external stitches. I add a little fat to blend the transition, and I often pair it with Morpheus to tighten the skin.
Hollows Are a Volume Problem, Not a Bag Problem
If the issue is hollowness rather than bags, I add volume with your own fat. The face has essentially no pain, and fat grafting under the eyes is very safe. I do it routinely, on facelifts and on younger faces that simply have less tissue.
It looks a little full at first, because you absorb about thirty to forty percent of grafted fat, so I slightly overfill. As it settles, it looks completely natural, because it is your own tissue.
My Strong Opinion on Under-Eye Filler
I am cautious about filler in that area, and I have seen what it does. Filler under the eyes can hold water and stay puffy for years, and it tends to migrate rather than fully dissolve.
Fat is the safer, more natural way to address true hollowing. If you already have problem filler there, dissolving it is often the first step before we do anything else.
Eyes, At a Glance
| What You See | What It Usually Is | What I Do |
|---|---|---|
| Heavy upper lid | Fold and extra skin | Remove the fold, scar hidden in the crease |
| Puffy lower bag | Fat bag | Remove from the inside, no external scar |
| Hollow, tired shadow | Volume loss | Fat grafting, slightly overfilled |
| Puffy for years | Old migrated filler | Dissolve first, then reassess |
“Will I Have Stitches Across My Lid? Will It Scar?”
Not visible ones. On the upper lid I place the sutures under the skin, so they do not leave the track marks you see in some photos. You might have two or three small ones that fall out on their own. On the lower lid, done from the inside, there are no external stitches at all.
As for keloids, on the eyelids and face they are almost unheard of. Keloids happen on the ears, shoulders, sternum, and joints. On the eyelids, I have never seen one.
What Recovery Is Really Like
The procedure takes under two hours. You are back to normal in three or four days, with some swelling and bruising. If you bruise, it can take up to two weeks, but usually after a week you can cover it with a little makeup. Exercise at four weeks.
To soften any old scars elsewhere, microneedling with PDGF, a growth factor stronger than PRP, works well over a few sessions at the Med Spa. ElixirMD LED therapy can speed the early healing.
Who I Think Should Have It, and Who Should Not
I am as quick to talk a patient out of eyelid surgery as into it. The right candidate can point to one specific thing, heavy upper lids, a lower bag, a tired shadow, rather than asking me to remake the eye. This is refinement, and patients who want transformation are usually asking the wrong procedure for the wrong reason.
The harder conversation is the patient whose tired look is really coming from the cheek dropping or the brow descending. In that face, an eyelid surgery alone chases the symptom. Sometimes the honest answer is a little fat, a brow that needs addressing, or a facelift, and I would rather say that than hand someone a procedure that will not fix what bothers them. Healthy non-smokers heal cleanest, and I am direct about that too.
Why I Work This Way
I am a double board-certified plastic surgeon with a plastic surgery fellowship at the Mayo Clinic, and I teach as a Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center Paul L. Foster School of Medicine. Eyelid work rewards restraint. The goal is for you to look rested, not operated on, and that comes from removing exactly what needs to go and hiding every incision.
See the Patient-Facing Versions
For the patient-facing walkthrough, see the companion post on agulloplasticsurgery.com. For the treatment menu, see the version on swplasticsurgery.com.
Ready to Talk?
If people keep asking why you look tired, your eyes may be the answer. Come in and let me take a look.
Call the office at (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or book online at agulloplasticsurgery.com. #StayBeautiful.
@RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.