Ricki Lake, Rosie O’Donnell and the Facelift After Weight Loss: What I Check Before Anyone Books

Ricki Lake smiling on the carpet at the Hulu premiere of The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox in New York, August 19, 2025, after her weight loss and the facelift she has described. Commentary by Frank Agullo, MD, FACS.

Two talk show hosts. Two facelifts. One argument about whether the first one was needed.

Ricki Lake says that when she had her facelift in 2024, Rosie O’Donnell told her it was unnecessary. Then, Lake says, O’Donnell lost about 50 pounds and booked her own. Lake also says she booked hers on impulse, after dropping about 40 pounds, with no research at all. Parade ran the story on October 31; Fox News and AOL picked it up the next day. No surgeon is named, and I am not going to name one or diagnose either woman from a headline.

Ricki Lake smiling on the carpet at the Hulu premiere of The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox in New York, August 19, 2025, after her weight loss and the facelift she has described. Commentary by Frank Agullo, MD, FACS.
Ricki Lake at the Hulu premiere of The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox at the New-York Historical Society, New York, August 19, 2025. Photo: lev radin/Shutterstock, editorial use.

I am going to say this, though: I see that exact sequence every week. A patient loses 40 or 50 pounds, usually on a GLP-1, looks in the mirror, and wants a facelift now. Some of them should have one. Some should wait. Here is how I tell the difference, in words I have already put on the record.

Why the Face Goes First

Nobody expects the face to be the first casualty of weight loss. It is.

“The biggest surprise patients see is the change in their face. The face doesn’t have a lot of fat, but the fat it does have is the good fat, the baby fat, what makes you look young.”

“We see the face just melt down because it’s lost all that volume. That’s usually the first thing they notice in the early stages of the weight loss.”

That is not a failure of willpower or of the diet. The skin does not care how the weight came off.

“It’s true, the skin doesn’t know how you did it. Patients lose the weight, the envelope stays, and some patients feel ashamed of it, like they did something wrong. That’s not the fact. It’s just the way things work.”

“Skin stops producing elastin after puberty, so it just doesn’t contract like it does during puberty.”

So when two women in their fifties and sixties drop a combined 90 pounds and both end up on a facelift table, I am not surprised. I have watched the pattern reshape my own practice.

“What I’ve seen in my practice is a lot more patients coming in for facial surgeries after massive weight loss with GLP-1 medications like semaglutide and tirzepatide.”

Check One: Is the Weight Done Moving?

This is the question I would ask either of them first, and it is the one an impulsive booking skips.

“Preferably I want the patient to have lost the weight that they had planned and be weight stable after any facelift procedure. The reason being that oftentimes patients after a facelift tend to lose further weight. And of course, if we lose the volume, then we will have some aging. As the face deflates, the skin tends to sag. So we would lose a lot of the benefit of having done the facelift if the patient continues to lose weight.”

How long is long enough? The GLP-1 timeline is shorter than the old bariatric one, and I have been tracking it.

“What I’ve been seeing is about a six to nine month weight loss and then about a three month stabilization until we’re ready for surgery.”

The other direction matters just as much.

“And the main thing is not to bounce back. When you stop taking it, if we have a bounce back, that can pretty much destroy everything we did, and the fat is not going to come back in the right places necessarily.”

Check Two: Is It Skin, Volume, or Both?

A face after major weight loss is usually two problems wearing one coat. There is loose skin, and there is missing fat. A lift addresses the first. It does nothing for the second.

“Fat is the best filler for a deflated face. A deflated face has lost fat. And what we do when we do fat grafting is replace the fat in those spaces. So it’s like with like.”

That is why almost every facelift I do after weight loss includes fat grafting, and why a lift alone can leave a patient tight but still hollow. The amount of excess skin also decides the operation.

“The differentiator is how much excess skin there is. If there’s substantial excess skin, then we do a deep plane open facelift with an incision in front of the ear. If there’s not a lot of excess skin, we can get away with doing everything through the incisions behind the hairline.”

What you see after 40 to 50 pounds What it usually is What addresses it
Jowls, a soft jawline, a loose neck Excess skin and a dropped deep layer Deep plane facelift and neck lift
Hollow temples, flat cheeks, deep under-eye grooves Lost facial fat Fat grafting, often at the same surgery
Crepey, thin, dry skin over everything Skin quality, not position Resurfacing, RF microneedling, retinoids
All of the above The typical GLP-1 face A plan, not a single procedure

Check Three: Were the Expectations Set, or Skipped?

“Realistic expectations. We have to set that from the beginning, otherwise nobody’s going to be happy.”

Booking with no research is how expectations go unset. A good consultation tells you what the lift will and will not do, and what the first six months look like.

“Patients who have lost a lot of weight, we do these surgeries and we’re pulling as tight as we can, but the skin, because it’s lost that elastin, is going to give again. We lose some of the result over the first six months.”

“A facelift is not finished healing at six weeks or even three months. A great many early complaints resolve on their own by month six.”

And when it is done well, on a stable weight, it holds.

“A well-executed deep plane facelift generally holds its lift for somewhere in the range of ten to fifteen years. Many patients never return to the starting point.”

“A healthy lifestyle, stable weight, and sun protection all go a long way in maintaining results.”

Check Four: Who Is Doing It?

The part of Lake’s account that worries me most is not the surgery. It is “no research.”

“I would stay away from anybody that has one or two or three amazing before and afters and that’s it. You want to see a surgeon that’s posting before and afters every day, and they’re all consistent, and they’re all getting good results.”

“I always feel like when things are too good to be true, they usually are. If a price seems far below what everyone else is charging, you have to ask what’s being cut, the surgeon’s experience, the accreditation of the facility, the type of anesthesia, or the follow-up care.”

Was O’Donnell wrong to call the first facelift unnecessary, then get her own? I have no idea, and neither does anyone reading the headlines. What I do know is that losing 50 pounds changes the answer. The surgical side of that decision, deep plane versus a skin-only lift once the weight is stable, is on my practice site. What the skin needs during the weight loss itself, before anyone operates, is on Southwest Plastic Surgery. I wrote about the face after weight loss in September, about what holds and what drifts at 18 months in October, and about the facelift you can’t see in April.

Why Choose Dr. Agullo

I am certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery and the American Board of Surgery, completed my plastic surgery fellowship at the Mayo Clinic, and serve as Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center. Castle Connolly has listed me as a Top Doctor every year from 2014 through 2026. Deep plane and total endoscopic deep plane facelifts are the center of my practice, and I prescribe and follow GLP-1 patients myself, so I see both halves of this story.

Ready to Talk?

Lost the weight and not sure what your face needs next? Come in and let me look before you book anything. Call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or request an appointment at agulloplasticsurgery.com/appointments. #StayBeautiful

Find me at @RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.